Made to order, crafted with love! 847.815.9108
Custom cutters and edible art for your perfect cookie.
Cookies with a Personal Touch
Hi! I'm glad you're here! I'm Denise Lee. I started Paddy Cakes Custom Cookies because I believe that every cookie tells a story. My journey began with making custom cakes (hence the name), but I fell in love with cookies and the ability to bring them to life with icing. Your loved ones can enjoy their cookie at your event or take it home. It is so much more versatile than a piece of cake! My cookies allow the decoration to be enjoyed longer. I treat every order as if I was making and decorating cookies for a loved one! I am truly honored to be able to add joy to your occasion with my creations and I am happy to work with you to come up with the design of your dreams! Our cookie cutters are made inhouse and personalized to you for each order. Take a minute to see a small sampling of my past orders. I look forward to creating something magnificent for your special occasion! XOXOXO Denise
Please note: This product is produced in a home kitchen not inspected by the health department that may also process common food allergens. If you have safety concerns, contact your local health department.
Weddings & Engagements
Explore our custom wedding and engagement cookie collections. We craft each treat to bring your special day to life!
25th Wedding Anniversary "cheers to 25 years" set
Engagement set
Engagement set
Engagement "duplicate ring" cookie
Engagement
50th Wedding Anniversary "we still do" set
Wedding
Wedding
Wedding -totally custom guest table assignment display, including personal message tags, close pins, white-washed boards, and set up.
"Brides maid dresses" set
Wedding shower "lavender" set
Baby Showers & New Arrivals
Discover our delightful baby shower and arrival cookie themes. Personalized just for your little one's celebration.
Baby shower "swan & flowers" set
Baby shower "baby it's cold outside" set
Baby shower "it's a girl" set
Baby shower "sip and see" set
Baby shower "baby boo" set
Baby shower "baby pooh & friends" set
Baby shower "cute as a button" set
Baby shower "girl" set
Gender reveal "Disney" set
Baby shower 2-D baby set
Baby shower "mommy to bee"
Birthday Fun
Explore some of our creative birthday cookie designs! We personalize each treat to turn your celebration into a sweet memory.
Birthday "21st"
Birthday "Wired light bulb Electrician 21st" set
Birthday "21st" set
Birthday "21st" set
Birthday "Hot wheels" set
Birthday "Dungeon's and Dragon's" set
Birthday "Bluey" set
Birthday "wild one" set
Birthday "1st rodeo" set
Birthday "unicorn" set
Birthday "21st" set
Birthday "50 & fabulous" set
Birthday "birthday notes" set
Birthday "13th racer "
Birthday "57th sunflower" set
Birthday "cupcake cookie"
Sports & Events
Check out our sporty cookie designs! We match your event's theme with handcrafted cookies that are as fun as they are delicious.
Sports "Cubs" set
Sports "Dayton softball" set
Sports "Niles West water polo" set
Sports "Skokie Flyers" set
Sports "D1 volleyball club" set
Cheerleading "Niles West Wolves" set
Sports "Niles West softball" set
Sports "Niles West soccer" set
Cheerleading "Glenbrook North Hello Kitty Cheer"
Seasonal Favorites
Explore our seasonal treats—each handcrafted to celebrate your special moments! Customization is our passion.
Winter "let it snow" set
4th of July "pop rock fire cracker" set
4th of July "celebration" set
Easter "bunnies and chicks" set
Christmas "Mr. & Mrs. Claus" set
Summer "BBQ" set
Easter 'Bunny puzzle cookie'
Halloween "cupcake cookie friends" set
"Eid Mubarak" set
Graduation & Achievements
Personalized cookies for celebrating your loved ones milestones .
Graduation "University of Kentucky" set
Graduation "Niles North High School" set
Graduation "University of Alabama" set
Graduation "University of Alabama" set
Sentimental Celebrations
Personalized cookies for your heartfelt moments. Crafted with heart, just for you.
Baptism
Baptism
Flower Cookie Bouquet
Flower Cookie Bouquet
Celebration of life
Flowers "lavender fields" set
Flowers "mini flower bouquet" set
Celebration of life "portraits on easels" set
"Tulip" set
"bees & flowers" set
"Cutie Bee" set
"Star Gazer Lily" set
Art show cookie on easel
"Non-verbal" cookie chart
"Fidget Spinner"
The Cookie Corner
A collection of "outside-the-box" orders that we have loved making!
"Layers Chicago GRAND OPENING" set
"Layers Chicago GRAND OPENING" Custom Display
"Stitch"
Hand painted -textured "Pit Bull"
Hand-painted "French Bulldog"
Labubu
Minions
Red Hat Society "Red Hat Lady"
Honey & Bees "Autumn Honey" set
Hand Painted/textured "Angry Cat"
"Superman"
"Superman"
"Dory"
"Trolls" set
"Pit Bull" set
"Betty Boop" set
"John Deer Farmer" set
Art exhibit "Laura Frisch" easel set
"Honda" cookie set
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Birthday "Over the hill"
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Birthday "Hot Wheels"
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Birthday "Go cart racer"
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Birthday "Tiffany blue"
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Birthday "Paleontologist"
NO LONGER AVAILABLE
Baby Shower "Baby Charlie"
FOLLOW US
Please note...
This product is produced in a home kitchen not inspected by the health department that may also process common food allergens. If you have safety concerns, contact your local health department.